Introduction: The Indian Premier League (IPL) 2024 has been a challenging arena for Rohit Sharma, the talismanic former captain of Mumbai Indians (MI). Once hailed as one of the most prolific batsmen and a five-time IPL champion leader, Rohit’s current form paints a starkly different picture. With a mere 82 runs in six innings at an abysmal average of 13.66, questions are mounting over his role in a struggling MI outfit. Is it time for the franchise, known for ruthless decisions, to reconsider their loyalty to the aging star?
The Decline: Rohit Sharma, at 38 years old, seems to be grappling with a prolonged slump. His best effort this season—a modest 26 off 16 balls against Sunrisers Hyderabad—stands as a bleak highlight in an otherwise forgettable campaign. Since 2022, his IPL batting average has plummeted to 22.89, the second-lowest among openers with 20-plus innings. Furthermore, he has crossed the 400-run mark in only one of the last five seasons, a far cry from the explosive hitter who once dominated bowlers. Among IPL openers this year, only Delhi Capitals’ Jake Fraser-McGurk fares worse, with 55 runs in six outings.
Team Impact: Mumbai Indians, currently languishing at seventh on the points table, are feeling the ripple effects of Rohit’s form under the leadership of Hardik Pandya. Head coach Mahela Jayawardene has openly voiced concerns over MI’s powerplay struggles, both with bat and ball. Despite a formidable bowling attack led by Jasprit Bumrah, the batting unit—spearheaded by Rohit—has faltered. Jayawardene, however, remains supportive, stating, ‘I still back the senior pros. We just need to be more ruthless.’ But with Rohit failing to bat beyond the powerplay in 24 of his last 36 IPL innings, including all games this year, the team’s early momentum often stalls.
Historical Context: Mumbai Indians are no strangers to making bold calls. Back in 2013, mid-season, they replaced captain Ricky Ponting with Rohit Sharma, a decision that led to their first IPL title. Over the years, MI’s scouting genius unearthed gems like Jasprit Bumrah, the Pandya brothers, and Ishan Kishan. Yet, their reluctance to address Rohit’s decline—despite fitness concerns and a recurring knee issue—raises eyebrows. Retaining a then-37-year-old Rohit before the auction now seems a decision rooted more in sentiment than strategy. As former India opener Virender Sehwag bluntly put it on Cricbuzz, ‘It’s your legacy that is getting hurt. It’s time for him to retire.’
Conclusion: Rohit Sharma’s legacy as the most successful IPL captain with five titles and his recent heroics in ending India’s ICC title drought at the 2024 T20 World Cup are undeniable. Yet, cricket is a game of present form, not past glories. Mumbai Indians, a franchise built on pragmatism, must decide how long they can afford to carry their weakest link at the top of the order. With emerging talents waiting in the wings and the IPL demanding ruthless adaptability, the clock might be ticking on Rohit’s tenure. Will MI make the tough call, or will nostalgia cloud their vision for another season?